MSSP vs MSP comes down to scope. CISA describes a managed service provider (MSP) as an entity that delivers, operates or manages ICT services for customers under a contract such as a service level agreement, and says its offerings may include cybersecurity services. NIST describes a managed security services provider (MSSP) as an outside provider that handles security work, such as round-the-clock monitoring of security devices. Neither agency draws one exact line between the two, so check each provider's contract.
What CISA Says About MSPs
CISA's advisory on protecting managed service providers and their customers defines MSPs as entities that deliver, operate or manage ICT services and functions for their customers through a contractual arrangement. An MSP may also offer services together with those of other providers. CISA lists platform, software and IT infrastructure services, business process and support functions, and cybersecurity services as possible offerings.
CISA adds that MSPs typically manage these services in the customer's network environment, either on the customer's premises or in the MSP's data center. The advisory says it does not cover cloud service providers.
What NIST Says About MSSPs
NIST's Computer Security Incident Handling Guide describes the most common MSSP arrangement. The organization outsources 24/7 monitoring of intrusion detection sensors, firewalls and other security devices to an offsite MSSP. The MSSP identifies and analyzes suspicious activity and reports each detected incident to the organization's incident response team.
NIST's SP 800-172 adds that an MSSP can provide an off-site security operations center where analysts monitor security-relevant data flows on behalf of multiple customers. An older NIST draft, SP 800-150, says an organization may use an MSSP for capabilities it cannot practically or cost-effectively build in-house, and that some organizations outsource all cybersecurity operations while others outsource only specific components.
MSSP vs MSP: What the Sources Say Side by Side
| Question | MSP (CISA) | MSSP (NIST) |
|---|---|---|
| What does it do? | Delivers, operates or manages ICT services and functions. | Provides security services, such as monitoring security devices. |
| How is it bought? | Contractual arrangement, such as a service level agreement. | Outsourced arrangement, often 24/7 monitoring. |
| Where does the work happen? | In the customer's network or the MSP's data center. | Often offsite, including an off-site security operations center. |
| Is security included? | Cybersecurity services are one possible offering. | Security is the core of the service. |
MSSP vs MSP: Shared Risks
CISA's guidance for MSPs and small and mid-sized businesses says MSPs generally have direct access to their customers' networks and data, which makes them a valuable target for cyber actors. In its remote monitoring and management plan, CISA says threat actors can use RMM software to gain footholds in MSP or MSSP servers and cause cascading effects for small and medium-sized customers.
CISA's risk considerations for MSP customers says that outsourcing the management of networks, cloud infrastructure and devices to an MSP does not remove an organization's own risk management responsibilities. The earlier advisory recommends applying the principle of least privilege and verifying that MSP accounts can reach only the systems the MSP manages.
Questions to Ask Before You Choose
NIST lists factors for outsourcing incident response, and they apply to either provider type:
- Quality of work: Assess current quality and the provider's ability to keep it up.
- Division of responsibilities: Document decision points, with the internal team making the final calls.
- Sensitive information: Limit what the provider can see, and consider non-disclosure agreements.
- Organization-specific knowledge: The provider needs current facts about critical resources and infrastructure changes.
- In-house skills: Keep basic incident response skills internally, in case the provider is unavailable.
Checklist: MSSP vs MSP Decision
- Write down which services you need: general IT operations, security monitoring or both.
- Read each contract for which security tasks are included, since CISA notes MSP offerings may include cybersecurity.
- Ask what access the provider gets to your network and apply least privilege.
- Decide who makes final calls during an incident.
- Keep basic response skills in-house.
This order is ours. CISA and NIST describe each point separately and do not publish one buying procedure.
What Do These Sources Not Say?
- CISA and NIST do not give one official definition that separates MSSP from MSP.
- They give no price, size or staffing comparison.
- We could not open the CISA pages in full, so the CISA points here rely on the excerpts that the search returned.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an MSSP a type of MSP?
CISA says MSP offerings may include cybersecurity services. Neither agency states whether an MSSP is a subset of an MSP.
Does an MSP replace my own security responsibility?
No. CISA says outsourcing does not absolve an organization of risk management responsibilities.
Which is better, MSSP vs MSP?
The sources do not rank them. NIST describes what an MSSP does and CISA describes what an MSP does, so the choice depends on the services you need.
What does an MSSP usually monitor?
NIST names intrusion detection sensors, firewalls and other security devices.
Key Takeaways
- MSSP vs MSP is mainly a question of scope: general IT services or security services.
- CISA says MSP offerings may include cybersecurity, so read the contract.
- Both provider types can have broad access to customer systems, which CISA flags as a risk.
- You keep your own risk management duties after outsourcing.
Sources and References
Facts follow CISA and NIST.
- Protecting Against Cyber Threats to Managed Service Providers and their Customers (CISA) www.cisa.gov
- CISA Insights: Guidance for MSPs and Small- and Mid-sized Businesses (CISA) www.cisa.gov
- CISA Insights: Risk Considerations for Managed Service Provider Customers (CISA) www.cisa.gov
- CISA Releases JCDC Remote Monitoring and Management (RMM) Cyber Defense Plan (CISA) www.cisa.gov
- Computer Security Incident Handling Guide, SP 800-61 Rev. 2 (NIST) nvlpubs.nist.gov
- Enhanced Security Requirements for Protecting CUI, SP 800-172 (NIST) nvlpubs.nist.gov
- Guide to Cyber Threat Information Sharing, SP 800-150 draft (NIST) csrc.nist.gov