This page covers how to choose an mssp using only NIST and CISA guidance. NIST's small business guidance starts with a clear list of the outcomes you want, then says to check providers, ask for quotes, and write the service levels and duties into a formal contract. It also says outsourcing does not move your liability to the provider. CISA's advisory adds that the contract should say who owns hardening, detection and incident response. If you are new to the term, read what an MSSP is first.
Step 1: List the Outcomes You Want
NIST says to begin with a clear list of cybersecurity outcomes you want the service to achieve, such as meeting certain requirements or goals. It also suggests using the NICE Framework to describe the cybersecurity work you need done.
The NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 Small Business Quick-Start Guide lists related first actions. These include understanding your legal, regulatory and contractual cybersecurity requirements, and knowing who in your business will run the cybersecurity strategy. The guide also says it can serve as a discussion prompt with a provider such as an MSSP.
Step 2: Check Providers and Request Quotes
NIST says to read online reviews to learn about other customers' experiences, and to confirm the provider can support your needs. Then request quotes from several vendors. A good first step is to know the difference between providers, so see MSSP vs MSP if both appear in your shortlist.
NIST does not explicitly discuss asking providers for client references. It points to online reviews instead. We note this as a gap below. Treat this step as the research part of how to choose an mssp: gather reviews and quotes before you talk contract terms with any single vendor.
Step 3: Ask Questions Beyond Price
NIST says not to compare on cost alone. Ask about the provider's experience in your industry and with small businesses, and how it would help you meet your legal, regulatory or contractual obligations.
CISA gives example questions in its insights on managed service provider risk. They include who is responsible for security and operations when you outsource, and which assets are most critical and how they are protected. CISA also points to a Vendor Supply Chain Risk Management Template with standard questions for vendors, and a guide that picks the questions most useful to small and medium businesses. The Insights document says you can also require self-attestations from a provider to show it follows industry standards.
Step 4: Put Responsibilities in the Contract
NIST says to document the level of service, each side's responsibilities and your expectations in a managed services agreement or other formal contract.
CISA's joint advisory on managed service providers says each customer should check that the contract meets its own security needs. It should state whether the provider or the customer owns duties such as hardening, detection and incident response. It also says customers should understand the security services the provider delivers, and address any requirement that falls outside the contract. Contracts should say how and when the provider notifies the customer. Our excerpt of that line was cut off, so read the full advisory.
CISA's Insights document lists further contract items. These are specific performance-related service level agreements, confirmation that the person signing is responsible for the service's security, and a duty to tell the customer about a change of provider ownership or leadership.
Step 5: Keep Ownership of the Risk
NIST says outsourcing does not transfer your liability. You stay responsible for protecting your systems and data. NIST SP 800-161 Rev. 1 adds that outsourcing reduces the buyer's visibility into and control of the outsourced work. It calls for more rigor in defining requirements, putting them in procurement agreements and monitoring the delivered service.
The 2022 CISA partner advisory also says to enforce multifactor authentication on provider accounts that access your environment, and to disable accounts no longer in use. For details on what an operations centre does, see our guide to the security operations center.
Once the contract is signed, how to choose an mssp turns into how to manage one. Keep reviewing the service against the duties you wrote down, and ask the provider for the information you need to do so.
Which Situation Fits You
- Small business with no in-house security staff: NIST says outsourcing is common here, and often the strategic choice.
- You want a way to start the talk with a provider: use the NIST Quick-Start Guide as a discussion prompt.
- You run a larger vendor programme: use NIST SP 800-161 Rev. 1 and the CISA vendor template.
- You are shortlisting by region: see our list of managed security providers in India.
These rows are our grouping, not NIST's. NIST says outsourcing is especially common for small businesses because they often lack the expertise, resources or budget for in-house staff. Larger organizations have more vendors to assess, so supply chain guidance fits them better.
This Order Is Ours, Not NIST's
NIST and CISA do not give one ranked process for how to choose an mssp. We arranged their points in the order a buyer meets them: outcomes, providers, questions, contract, ongoing ownership. Use it as a checklist, and adjust it to your risk.
What Do These Sources Not Say?
- NIST does not explicitly discuss asking providers for client references.
- None of the pages we read gives a scoring sheet, weights or a pass mark for providers.
- None gives price ranges for MSSP services.
- The CISA documents are written about managed service providers in general. We applied them to MSSPs, and that reading is ours.
- None of the pages we read names which certifications a provider must hold.
- Several CISA pages date from 2022 or earlier, so check for newer versions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the first step to choose an MSSP?
NIST says to start with a clear list of the cybersecurity outcomes you want the service to achieve.
Should I choose an MSSP on price alone?
No. NIST says not to compare on cost alone, and to ask about industry experience and help with your legal, regulatory or contractual obligations.
What should the MSSP contract include?
NIST says the level of service, responsibilities and expectations. CISA adds who owns hardening, detection and incident response, and how and when the provider notifies you.
Does hiring an MSSP transfer my liability?
NIST says it does not. You remain responsible for protecting your systems and data.
Do official pages give a scoring checklist?
Not in the pages we read. The order on this page is ours, not NIST's or CISA's.
Where can I find standard vendor questions?
CISA publishes a Vendor Supply Chain Risk Management Template and a small business guide built from it. NIST also points to the NDISAC Managed Service Provider Shopping Guide.
Key Takeaways
- Start with outcomes, compare on more than cost, and put duties in writing.
- Outsourcing does not move your liability.
- Check who owns hardening, detection and incident response.
- Review the service against the contract after you sign.
- No official page we read gives a scoring checklist.
Sources and References
Facts follow NIST and CISA publications.
- Building Your Small Business's Cybersecurity Team (NIST) www.nist.gov
- NIST CSF 2.0 Small Business Quick-Start Guide (NIST SP 1300) nvlpubs.nist.gov
- NIST SP 800-161 Rev. 1 nvlpubs.nist.gov
- CISA Insights: Risk Considerations for Managed Service Provider Customers www.cisa.gov
- Going Beyond: Assessing Security Practices of IT Service Providers (CISA) www.cisa.gov
- Protecting Against Cyber Threats to Managed Service Providers and their Customers (CISA AA22-131A) www.cisa.gov
- CISA Joins Partners to Release Advisory on Protecting MSPs and their Customers us-cert.cisa.gov